Why Screen Printing Still Rules in a Digital World. People have been saying screen printing is on its way out since inkjet machines showed up in the 1990s. Thirty years later it’s still here. Walk into most print shops and you’ll find a rack of mesh screens and somebody covered in ink who doesn’t look worried at all.
Digital printing is great, no argument there. But screen printing still rules in a digital world for practical reasons, mostly to do with money, colour and what you’re printing on. Here’s how it plays out.
How the two methods work
A screen is a piece of fine mesh stretched over a aluminum or wooden frame. A stencil blocks most of the mesh and leaves your art design open. Set the screen on a shirt, scoop some ink on top and pull a squeegee across. Ink goes through the open parts only. That’s the whole trick. Every colour in a design needs its own screen, so a five colour design means five screens and a lot of careful lining up the design.
Digital printing, including direct to garment, works more like a large office printer. It reads a file and sprays ink direct onto the exposed fabric. No screens, no stencils.
Colour is where screen printing wins first
The ink goes on thick. It sits on the surface instead of sinking into the fibers, which gives you strong, flat colour with set sharp edges. A white print on a black hoodie looks properly white and defined.
Shops can also mix ink to match a Pantone shade. If your brand blue has to be that exact blue, a screen printer can get there. Digital machines build color from a few base inks, and some shades just don’t come out right, certain blues and oranges mostly. Plenty of designers have opened a box of shirts and found their logo slightly off. It happens more than anyone admits. White ink on dark fabric is another sore spot for digital. It costs more, and it often looks thinner.
Prints that outlast the shirt
Once the ink is cured with heat, a good screen print holds up through a lot of washing. Everything fades eventually, sure, but a thick layer of plastisol ink usually outlasts a thin digital print. That’s why work uniforms, school merch and the band tee you’ve worn for ten years are usually screen printed.
The money side
Setup is the catch. Somebody has to make the screens, mix the ink and line everything up before the first shirt comes out. If you only want one shirt, that’s a silly amount of work. If you want 500, the setup cost gets divided so many times you barely notice it.
Digital has hardly any setup, so it’s cheaper for small orders. Ten shirts, each with a different photo? Digital, easy. Eight hundred shirts with the same logo for a company event? Screen printing will cost less per shirt, often by a lot. Printers call the point where the two prices meet the break even point, and it’s worth asking your shop where it sits for your job. It can save you real money.
It prints on more than fabric
Screens can print on cotton, polyester, canvas, paper, wood, metal, glass and plastic. A lot of hard, nonabsorbent surfaces don’t take regular digital ink well, so screen printing does that work. It’s also used in printed electronics, like parts of circuit boards, which surprises most people.
Then there are the effects. Puff ink swells up when it’s heated. Metallic ink shines. Glow in the dark ink does exactly what it says. Digital machines mostly can’t do any of that.
Where digital is better
Photos. Tiny details. Smooth colour gradients. Rush jobs. Print on demand sellers can upload a design and ship it without holding any stock, which is hard to beat for a small shop testing ideas.
Plenty of print shops use both now, and some machines mix the two, printing digital color on top of a screen printed base. Shops don’t pick sides. They pick whatever suits the job on the table.
Artists never left
Andy Warhol made silkscreen famous with his celebrity portraits. Shepard Fairey’s Obey posters started as screen prints, and he’s still using the method today. Collectors like that prints are pulled by hand, so no two come out exactly the same. A digital file can be copied forever. A screen print has a person’s hands all over it.
Which one should you choose?
Ask yourself three set defining questions. How many printed are you needed ? How precise are you about the set colours? and what are you printing the design on?
Big batch, exact colors or a stubborn surface: go with screen printing. Small batch, photo style detail or a deadline tomorrow: go digital. If you can’t decide, ask the print shop. They’d rather answer a question than redo an order.
Screen printing has been called dead more than once. The squeegee is still moving.
Final Thoughts
Screen printing is not about to die out, and here's why. It provides you with "thick" and "bold" color which can be a match to a Pantone color. Makes prints that last for years in washing. It becomes less expensive by the piece with larger quantities ordered and can be used on surfaces that digital machines cannot reach, such as glass and circuit boards. Digital printing is certainly not without its advantages, such as photo quality, small runs and turnaround time and there is no true winner here. There's just the right way to do the task at hand.
When ordering t shirts for a team, business or even an event, make sure you have a good count, understanding of your colours and know how long you want the print design to last for. The three answers listed above will help guide you in the direction you will need to go. Are you still stuck? The good print shop will be glad to help. Machines will continue to evolve, but a little bucked-up mesh and a squeegee will suffice!
To find out about my new artwork please join the mailing list.